Homemade Frosty Paws: 7 Dog Ice Cream Recipes!

Does your dog love Frosty Paws (dog ice cream)? Learn how to make Homemade Frosty Paws with only 3 ingredients!

The scorching days of Summer can make anyone long for an ice cream treat, even a dog! Frosty Paws are ice cream that is made by Purina and can be found in a lot of pet stores and grocery stores in the frozen foods section.

These little dog ice cream treats can start to take a major strain on your wallet. You can still treat your dog to some ice cream and keep more money in the bank by making homemade frosty paws.

These dog ice cream treats are so simple to make, the hardest part is just waiting for them to freeze.

Be sure to check out all 7 Dog Ice Cream Recipes below!

Homemade Frosty Paws Recipe:

(1) 32 oz. container of All-Natural Plain or Vanilla-Flavored Yogurt (If your dog is lactose-intolerant you can substitute with soy-yogurt instead.)
(1) cup of All-Natural Peanut Butter
(2) ripe bananas (If you have babies you can also substitute a large container of banana baby food for this.)
(1) package of small Dixie cups or (1) ice cream molds tray

Optional: You can also add honey or fruit like strawberries or blueberries. Another good option would be pureed canned pumpkin (not pie filling).

Try Different Ice Cream Ingredients:

So you can make various flavored recipes all from what you already have on hand! It’s very simple.

More Dog Ice Cream Recipes:

Strawberry Frosty Paws Dog Ice Cream Recipe:

(1) 32 oz. container of All-Natural Plain or Vanilla-Flavored Yogurt (If your dog is lactose-intolerant you can substitute with soy-yogurt instead.)
(6) Strawberries (fresh or frozen). Cut up or blend into yogurt.
(1) cup of All-Natural Peanut Butter
(2) ripe bananas (If you have babies you can also substitute a large container of banana baby food for this.)

Blueberry Frosty Paws Dog Ice Cream Recipe:

(1) 32 oz. container of All-Natural Plain or Vanilla-Flavored Yogurt (If your dog is lactose-intolerant you can substitute with soy-yogurt instead.)
(1/4 cup) Blueberries (fresh or frozen). Add whole or blend into yogurt.
(1) cup of All-Natural Peanut Butter
(2) ripe bananas (If you have babies you can also substitute a large container of banana baby food for this.)

Peanut Butter Honey Frosty Paws Dog Ice Cream Recipe:

(1) 32 oz. container of All-Natural Plain or Vanilla-Flavored Yogurt (If your dog is lactose-intolerant you can substitute with soy-yogurt instead.)
(1) cup of All-Natural Peanut Butter
(1 teaspoon) All Natural Honey
(2) ripe bananas (If you have babies you can also substitute a large container of banana baby food for this.)

Pumpkin Frosty Paws Dog Ice Cream Recipe:

(1) 32 oz. container of All-Natural Plain or Vanilla-Flavored Yogurt (If your dog is lactose-intolerant you can substitute with soy-yogurt instead.)
(1/2) cup canned pureed pumpkin. (*Make sure to use plain canned pumpkin, NOT pumpkin pie filling.) Blend into yogurt.
(1) cup of All-Natural Peanut Butter
(2) ripe bananas (If you have babies you can also substitute a large container of banana baby food for this.)

Apple Frosty Paws Dog Ice Cream Recipe:

(1) 32 oz. container of All-Natural Plain or Vanilla-Flavored Yogurt (If your dog is lactose-intolerant you can substitute with soy-yogurt instead.)
(1) cup all-natural unsweetened applesauce. Blend into yogurt.
(1) cup of All-Natural Peanut Butter
(2) ripe bananas (If you have babies you can also substitute a large container of banana baby food for this.)

Watermelon Frosty Paws Dog Ice Cream Recipe:

(1) 32 oz. container of All-Natural Plain or Vanilla-Flavored Yogurt (If your dog is lactose-intolerant you can substitute with soy-yogurt instead.)
(1) cup cut seedless watermelon. Blend into yogurt.
(1) cup of All-Natural Peanut Butter
(2) ripe bananas (If you have babies you can also substitute a large container of banana baby food for this.)

You can make Strawberry Frosty Paws, Blueberry Frosty Paws, Peanut Butter Honey Frosty Paws, Pumpkin Frosty Paws, Apple Frosty Paws, etc. The possibilities and combinations are almost endless! Let us know what you come up with in the comments. :)

How to Make Frosty Paws:

1. Blend all ingredients with a blender, food processor or mixer. Once all ingredients are smooth then pour into equal portions into the Dixie cups or in the ice cream molds.

*You can also use this dog ice cream mixture as a way to stuff your dog’s Kong.

Pour the homemade frosty paws mixture into the Kong, then put the Kong in the freezer to freeze. Pull out the Kong when frozen and let your dog enjoy!

Easy as that! You’ll have homemade frosty paws ready to go in the freezer whenever your pup needs a nice cool treat.